WDYT of this sib set?

Hmm, I was a huge Pokémaniac back in the day also, but I didn't remember Roselia until I looked it up. 

DH doesn't like Gloria and I think Glory is too short for a first name. Glorianna is the only form of Gloria that we both agree on.

Rosalia - Adoraaaabbbleee.

Rowan - I think this is a very cute name. Rory could be a nickname?

Glorianna - This feels very overdone next to your other names. Why not just Gloria?

Phoenix - Very cute, a bit out there... but I like it! Nix could be a cute n/n

Other Ideas:

Ivy, Camilla, Primrose, Zinnea, Saffron, Isla, Skylar, Winter, Aster, Holly, Iris, Juniper, Laurel, Lily, Violet

Asher, Grover, Cole, Skylar, Oliver, Reed/Reid, River, Stone,  Forrest, Linden,  August

LOVE Rosalia, it's a great name and I love Rosie as a nickname. It's elegant, classic, feminine, and unique. 

Rowan is cute, not my favorite but I like it. I don't think it needs a nickname. I don't like Row haha.

I don't like the name Glorianna.

Phoenix is unique. Not my style but it could grow on me and I like Nick as a nickname. Some other nns are Nix, Nick, Finn

We are pronouncing Rosalia as Rose-uh-lee-uh. :) I never played Pokemon (though I've heard of it) so I never thought of that. DH says Rosalie (Rose-uh-lee) sounds like it's cut off short, but says the 'uh' completes it. As for the nickname Morning Glory for Glorianna, it would be a family pet name, I wouldn't shout it across a playground or use it in public. I'd probably use Glory/Gloria. Glorianna is a bit long, I agree, but DH hates Gloria and Glory is too short for a full name to me. Glorianna is the only form of Gloria that DH likes (I found 27 forms with various spelling variations).

Would Rory be too much of a stretch for a nickname for Rowan? I like Nix and Phee/Fee/Phoe for nicknames for Phoenix, though I'd probably use Nix. I just would like nickname options and then add to the nickname pool/list as we discover the baby's personality.

I think I like Rosalie (ROH-zuh-lee)  better than Rosalia (I'm saying ro-ZALE-ee-uh, not roh-zuh-LEE-uh). Rosie is an adorable nickname.

I love Rowan! It's at the top of my list right now. I am a bit strange so the nicknames I would go for would be Ro/Row (obviously), but I also like Captain (because he's rowin' a boat) and that turns into Walt or Abe (because of the Walt Whitman poem "Oh Captain! My Captain!" which is about Abraham Lincoln). So, I have this way too planned out for someone who won't be having kids for another ten years, haha.

Gloriana and Phoenix aren't really my style!

I love Rowan and Phoenix together, they're gorgeous and would make lovely brothers.

However, I don't like the girls names. Rosalia is fine but I'm not keen on Glorianna, I mean it's OK but nothing I'd use. I guess Glory and Gloria are sweet enough nicknames but I think people might give you funny looks shouting Glorianna across the school playground - I might be wrong though!

Also, please don't inflict the nickname 'Morning Glory' on your daughter, see this link for the reason why (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=morning%20glory). I personally wouldn't want anyone to catch on to this!

Rowan doesn't really need a nickname, and neither does Phoenix but I like the nn Nix.

Rosalia - I really like a lot of Rose- names, but Rosalia's one I personally avoid. I'm kind of a huge Pokemon nerd, have been since I was a kid, and Roselia (with an e, not an a) is a Pokemon, so.... It's just not something I would use. I don't think a lot of people would think of that connotation, but it would bother me...

Rowan - LOVE. I didn't know it was the Celtic tree of life, that's really cool. I don't really think it needs a nickname, it's simple enough as it is.... Row would be an obvious one, maybe as something more casual...

Glorianna - When I was 4 and my mom was pregnant with my sister, I wanted more than anything for my parents to name her Gloria. I have no idea where I'd heard the name, but I loved it. And I was so mad when they named her Haley instead. So, Gloria has a special place in my heart. Glorianna seems too unnecessarily long for my tastes...

Phoenix - While I don't think I'd use it, theres a good handful of people who really like it. I think it sounds really good with the other names, Rowan and Phoenix sound great as brothers!

If you have seen my posts in the Some Names We've Heard Lately board, we have unusual names here too. But that's probably due to a lot of foreign students coming to our college to get degrees. Phoenix seems a bit tame to me, but then again I've seen names that are 10 letters long and that I have no clue how to pronounce.

Yeah, Acorn beats Phoenix in oddness. I guess I'm a name conservative because I was brought up in a preppy white suburb where most people's names are "average." (Elizabeth, Susan, Alexandra, Nicholas, Thomas, Andrew...)

It might just be where we live, but we have names that I find to be odder than Phoenix. I went to school (college) with a guy named Acorn and he was not a Native (we live near a reservation).